new X650's - first impressions

U

ulendo

Guest
well - stopped in to look at the new 'X' bikes at SWMotorad in kelowna. Nice looking bikes. All three are very much stripped out machines compared to the F650 GS series, are single seat only ( no passenger pegs, and the muffler location precludes a passenger anyway), and look to be very much aimed at the adventure / dualsport crowd. the Xmoto, and Xchallange share 90% of the bodywork, but have some significant differences mechanically. My only real gripe with any of them is the small underseat fuel tank.

the Xcountry is close in looks to an older standard - think vintage CB350, but equipped with better suspension, and multipurpose wheels and rubber. On the floor, seat is about 31", and overall it strikes me as a real world commuter / light backroads bike. It'll probably make a very, very good first bike, and I suspect its intent is to get new riders into BMW dealerships

the Xmoto is a mean looking, nicely tricked out minimalist supermoto. standard seat is ~35", but BMW list a low thats around 33". 53HP and 350 lbs is a bit underpowered for the bracket, but asa first entry to the class,it certainly leaves an impression. 10.5" front travel, and 8.5" rear, and it looked as though both are adjustable for preload, and at least one damping mode. Given its weight, evena shorter rider like myselfcan manage the height, albeit, I've only got my knee hooked over the seat when stopped.

the XChallange looks like a nice, lightweight alternative to the HP2. rear air suspension, really good clearance, minimalist, but functional. Seat is ~36", but, again, weight, and balance mean that even a shortrider can just manage it. Travel is roughly 10.5" front and rear.Didnt get a chance to ride it, but it looks like its well on the way tothe technical, but streetable bike many folks have been looking for - best descrpition I can come up with is a (functional) cross between a Supermoto, and a trials bike, which would make it close to ideal for the mixed riding conditions in BC.

for me, it'd be a toss up between the Xmoto, and the Xchallenge - possibly favoring the Xchallange as a companion to my Buell.
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

ulendo wrote:
well - stopped in to look at the new 'X' bikes at SWMotorad in kelowna. Nice looking bikes. All three are very much stripped out machines compared to the F650 GS series, are single seat only ( no passenger pegs, and the muffler location precludes a passenger anyway), and look to be very much aimed at the adventure / dualsport crowd. the Xmoto, and Xchallange share 90% of the bodywork, but have some significant differences mechanically. My only real gripe with any of them is the small underseat fuel tank.

the Xcountry is close in looks to an older standard - think vintage CB350, but equipped with better suspension, and multipurpose wheels and rubber. On the floor, seat is about 31", and overall it strikes me as a real world commuter / light backroads bike. It'll probably make a very, very good first bike, and I suspect its intent is to get new riders into BMW dealerships

the Xmoto is a mean looking, nicely tricked out minimalist supermoto. standard seat is ~35", but BMW list a low thats around 33". 53HP and 350 lbs is a bit underpowered for the bracket, but asa first entry to the class,it certainly leaves an impression. 10.5" front travel, and 8.5" rear, and it looked as though both are adjustable for preload, and at least one damping mode. Given its weight, evena shorter rider like myselfcan manage the height, albeit, I've only got my knee hooked over the seat when stopped.

the XChallange looks like a nice, lightweight alternative to the HP2. rear air suspension, really good clearance, minimalist, but functional. Seat is ~36", but, again, weight, and balance mean that even a shortrider can just manage it. Travel is roughly 10.5" front and rear.Didnt get a chance to ride it, but it looks like its well on the way tothe technical, but streetable bike many folks have been looking for - best descrpition I can come up with is a (functional) cross between a Supermoto, and a trials bike, which would make it close to ideal for the mixed riding conditions in BC.

for me, it'd be a toss up between the Xmoto, and the Xchallenge - possibly favoring the Xchallange as a companion to my Buell.

Just checked the literature and the X-Countryhas passenger pegs standard and all the others have them optional.I've seen theX-country sporting factorysoft bags and a 'screen too.

The brochure says they have compression and rebound damping on the front and rebound on the back.

They also say you can get a full Ti exhaust system for them from BMW.
 
U

ulendo

Guest
imported post

imported post

all 3 use the same frame.



here's a good side pic of the Xcountry - not sure where/how youd fit passanger pegs that allow a passengers legto clear the muffler ( its quite wide, and sticks out well past the LHS body & frame.) For reference, the riders footpeg is located below, and slightly to the rear of the swingarm pivot. The seats on the other two bikes are more of a solo format anyway, as are the general riding style for trails, and supermoto

P0030505.JPG


I couldnt find a photo of it, but the one at SWMotorrad (Xcountry) has lash points on the back that look like grab handles, but are only rated for ~30lbs. luggage I've seen looks like touratech soft bags - I'll have to see if I can get a test ride, and find out what gear is available.
 

Buck

Moderator
imported post

imported post

ulendo wrote:
53HP and 350 lbs is a bit underpowered for the bracket, but asa first entry to the class,it certainly leaves an impression.


Thought other stock 650s (KLR, DR) had about 35-40HP. A road test will tell the story. Looking forward to a ride on the supermoto when the demos show up.

When would that be Brian?? :dr:

Good write up, thanks for that.
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

00Buck wrote:
ulendo wrote:
53HP and 350 lbs is a bit underpowered for the bracket, but asa first entry to the class,it certainly leaves an impression.


Thought other stock 650s (KLR, DR) had about 35-40HP. A road test will tell the story. Looking forward to a ride on the supermoto when the demos show up.

When would that be Brian?? :dr:

Good write up, thanks for that.
The X-Challenge will be in next week. The test day is May 1st.
 
U

ulendo

Guest
imported post

imported post

kelly @ SWmotorrad has the Xchallenge on the floor right now, so I'm not sure where you're getting the 'next week' date from. Hadnt seen the pegs on the BMW site ( euro site??) , and either Kellys bike is non-standard, or they're not standard for this market, cause the one on the floor definitely didnt have them. Having seen thebike, even with pegs, I dont think I'd want to carry, or be a passanger on one: they are VERY small framed bikes, with less actual saddle space than my cityX. As for the farkles, I looked through the catalogue while I was there - there's a lot more than illustrated on thewebsite.

RE: power output - the new aprilia supermoto is a 70HP 550, in a lighter bike ( ~295 lbs IIRC ),Husaberg 550SM is 62HP, and the Husky610SM is~65HP, so 53 HP from a 650 is definitely not a power machine for a supermoto. comparable bikes for the Xchallengewould be the HuskyTE510, and Husaberg 550 enduro...again, both of which make more than 53HP. Price point goes to BMW for a change though, and the fit, and finish on the f650X's looks to be very good.

dont get me wrong - powers definitely not the only thing, they're nice bikes, and given some recent job changes, its very, very likely that I'll end up with either an Xchallenge, or Xmoto sometime over the next year, but geesh, dont putthe BMW blue blinders on either!!
 
U

ulendo

Guest
imported post

imported post




was having login/editing difficulties - no delete button for the extra post.
 

windaddiction

New member
imported post

imported post

lets not kid ourselves that aprillia is no street bike... my buddies caught on fire after 2 months.... the major plus to the BMW is maintance intervals! you want power you're gonna pay for it in maintance...
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

I didn't say the passenger would be comfortable I just said they'd have pegs!

My wife has only riden once on the HP2. I guess it's more of a 'your buddies bike is broken and here's the only way he's getting out' type passenger ride.
 
U

ulendo

Guest
imported post

imported post

wouldnt know 1st hand, but the 450/550 SVX, and SRX are getting good user feedback from Europe. Pretty funny comment though when over on ADVrider, its been brought up thatAprilia had technical input on thenew X bikes, too...brigns up the question of how much Pegaso, and SVX arein the new 650X's??

FWIW, Kelowna Yamaha are tring to get back into Aprilia, and according to Colin there, are hoping to have a 550 SM on the floor by the end of the month - I'll see if I can arrange test rides for the Xmoto, and 550 Aprilia on the same day to give back-to-back imprssions
 

SubMann

New member
imported post

imported post

Don't forget to compare the service intervals as windaddiction said. I think the Aprilia needs a rebuild after 60 or 80 hours. The BMW will need an oil change after what 6000 or more km? They are totaly different bikes built for different purposes. For me I'd rather be ridin' than wrenchin'. With the Aprillia I'd be rebuilding it every two or three months! That's insane.

Had to edit: 10,000km oil change and 3 year warranty

ulendo wrote:
wouldnt know 1st hand, but the 450/550 SVX, and SRX are getting good user feedback from Europe. Pretty funny comment though when over on ADVrider, its been brought up thatAprilia had technical input on thenew X bikes, too...brigns up the question of how much Pegaso, and SVX arein the new 650X's??

FWIW, Kelowna Yamaha are tring to get back into Aprilia, and according to Colin there, are hoping to have a 550 SM on the floor by the end of the month - I'll see if I can arrange test rides for the Xmoto, and 550 Aprilia on the same day to give back-to-back imprssions
 
U

ulendo

Guest
imported post

imported post

service intervals dont bother me - and the HOUR rated services from aprilia are references for race use, not the roadgoing intervals. Usual rule of thumb for the service engines I've dealt with that have both hour meters, and odometersis hours to km is converted at 'cruising speed' so 60-80 * 100 (kilometers per hour) would give service intervals in the 6000-8000km range for conventional riding that isnt hammering the bike all the time.

By the same token, a hard used F650X Moto isnt going to go 10,000 between oil changes, and true supermoto style riding WILL break things, and wear things faster than conventional riding. ( not to mention they get low-sided one hell of a lot!!) Anyone seen a race based service interval for the F650XMoto yet?

Personally, I wouldnt generallyride ANY bike 10k between oil changes, and at least a minor service and equipment check. I guess I should add that I wouldnt consider ANY trail, trials or supermoto as anything other than atoy, at which point, ride what turns your crank, so to speak.
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

ulendo wrote:
service intervals dont bother me - and the HOUR rated services from aprilia are references for race use, not the roadgoing intervals. Usual rule of thumb for the service engines I've dealt with that have both hour meters, and odometersis hours to km is converted at 'cruising speed' so 60-80 * 100 (kilometers per hour) would give service intervals in the 6000-8000km range for conventional riding that isnt hammering the bike all the time.

By the same token, a hard used F650X Moto isnt going to go 10,000 between oil changes, and true supermoto style riding WILL break things, and wear things faster than conventional riding. ( not to mention they get low-sided one hell of a lot!!) Anyone seen a race based service interval for the F650XMoto yet?

Personally, I wouldnt generallyride ANY bike 10k between oil changes, and at least a minor service and equipment check. I guess I should add that I wouldnt consider ANY trail, trials or supermoto as anything other than atoy, at which point, ride what turns your crank, so to speak.

The "normal" oil interval is 10,000KM. At the shop we recommend 5,000KM for what most people use their bikesfor. If you are really scorching the tires off the bike/doing huge amounts of very hard dirt riding possibly go as low as 2,500KM, but that is extreme use only.

I haven't seen an official "race" duty service schedule yet.

The Aprillias are very cool bikes but are going to be a little too race oriented for some.

Good rides are not usually so much about what you ride but that you ride.

Brian
 

SubMann

New member
imported post

imported post

ulendo wrote:
service intervals dont bother me - and the HOUR rated services from aprilia are references for race use, not the roadgoing intervals. Usual rule of thumb for the service engines I've dealt with that have both hour meters, and odometersis hours to km is converted at 'cruising speed' so 60-80 * 100 (kilometers per hour) would give service intervals in the 6000-8000km range for conventional riding that isnt hammering the bike all the time.

By the same token, a hard used F650X Moto isnt going to go 10,000 between oil changes, and true supermoto style riding WILL break things, and wear things faster than conventional riding. ( not to mention they get low-sided one hell of a lot!!) Anyone seen a race based service interval for the F650XMoto yet?

Personally, I wouldnt generallyride ANY bike 10k between oil changes, and at least a minor service and equipment check. I guess I should add that I wouldnt consider ANY trail, trials or supermoto as anything other than atoy, at which point, ride what turns your crank, so to speak.
True, but there is the minor difference of a rebuild and oil change.
 

deuce

New member
imported post

imported post

BMWNut wrote:
Good rides are not usually so much about what you ride but that you ride.

Brian


:hb:Cheers to that Brian. So, what are the prices for these 'Entry Level' Beemers??
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

The X-Country is $10,500: The X-Challenge is $11,000; and the X-Moto is $11,500. Plus $850 for ABS if you want and PDI/Freight/tax.
 

eagleguy

New member
imported post

imported post

Hi, I have the x challenge, and it is great. Can you help me with the chain tension, the manual says about 25 mm play on the side stand. I have that, but when I put my weight on the bike, it gets tight. Should I slacken a little more, thanks Steve
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

eagleguy wrote:
Hi, I have the x challenge, and it is great. Can you help me with the chain tension, the manual says about 25 mm play on the side stand. I have that, but when I put my weight on the bike, it gets tight. Should I slacken a little more, thanks Steve
We looked at the chain on the one we rec'd and the head mechanic thought it was too tight so we loosened it a few turns. It came from the factory set to about "middle C".
 
Top