imported post
imported post
DSN_650 on Yahoo have been talking a lot on this subject so you can get some great advice there.
I recommend the HT Teton panniers with Canyon Cut profile and make sure that you get aluminum panniers powder coated or your gear will turn black from rubbing the oxide. Aluminum panniers are very tough and repairable to new condition. Plastics are more difficult to repair to look and work like new if bashed (IMO).
You also may wish to consider the consequences of having the hard bag/pannier hit the back of a leg which was planted without considering the consequences.... Ask older Gold Wing riders about this risk.
I don't like spoft bags for my riding because they are (IMO) more difficult to seal, clean mud and dust from, secure against theft and so on. Just my $0.02. Some have recommended bicycle luggage as being better value so this may be worth consideration if going the soft luggage route.
Here's one post I sent on the subject and am too lazy (VBG) to retype:
Bob, IMO you are best advised to decide on the bags/panniers which you intend to use and then to select racks. My HT Teton aluminium panniers fill the needs well and the racks are out of the way when the panniers are stored which is most of the time.
The HT racks are well made and have a solid record of reliability. No one seems to have mentioned the issue of reliability because it really goes without saying but for that reason it can also be over looked. A major issue on a back country trip (IMO) is getting there and back without having anything break. Most people seem to ignore the consequences of having a broken rack or other hardware but this kind of failure will become a huge problem off road!
As Julia said, "Really big mistake! Huge!"
I urge you to consider the various choices in light of how you rate their reliability and go with the most reliable set-up which fits your needs. It will be far better to have the wrong set of bags make the whole trip than to have the right ones banging around on a broken rack.
Despite having access to materials and the best welding available (not my welding) I decided on HT racks because both the engineering and fabrication have a proven (no reported failures according to the sites I monitor) record.
The HT racks are top dollar and perhaps over priced but I am buying insurance also.
Consider factoring in the cost of wondering if the rack will break and consider how much you are willing to pay to avoid this. Also consider how much you would be willing to pay to have someone repair that broken rack on a Sunday evening in the pouring rain when you should have been home two hours ago.......
While this reasoning does not apply to everyone's line of thinking it is how I proceeded in attempting to weight these factors.
If you are unsure as to whether you might like to use hard (panniers)or soft bags, (IMO) you will be well advised to select a set of racks which can accommodate either type. The addition of a pair of panels to the HT racks will allow them to hold any soft bags away from the KLR's coachwork and exhaust.
I am not trying to sell you on the HT racks but rather suggesting a line of thinking which you can likely improve on in making your selection.
Happy trails to you (VBG)
Norm
Chilliwack, Canada