Would you buy a 1200GSA without ABS?

M

MV NV

Guest
imported post

imported post

Well Hello - I just picked up a new R1200GSA 2 weeks ago - without ABS.
The tough decision was ABS or NO ABS.

It came down to price and availability. The shop had one unit in stock without ABS. Even though it is a $1800 option, to get a bike in from Alberta with ABS and a few other options that I didn't want it was going to be a $4000 up charge. They even dropped the list price by $1000 for me to take their bike - which I obvioulsy did.

Teh GSA's are really in limited supply - with pretty much all the next shipment accounted for, until say Spring. You may not have much choice in options if you want to ride before the spring.

A friend here, has a R1200GSA with ABS, he's ridden 21K kms this year and has not used it once. In four years of riding on bikes with ABS, he says has not used it at all. The pain is deactiving it when going off road - everytime you start your engine.

I have ridden 30+ years without it and seem confident in my riding skills that will be continue to be the case.

Jim
White Rock
 
S

Smoky

Guest
imported post

imported post

I have a BMW RT road bike, with ABS.

When it was about a month old, I was most of the way through an unseen stop sign in Podunk WA. I hit the brakes so hard I slid up on the tank and wasn't going to be able to reach the ground. Seeing as I was almost stopped, and wasn't going to hit anything, I lifted off the brakes and rolled throught the intersection.

That's the fasted I've ever seen a bike, almost come to a stop from about 60 kmh.

I've since added about 90,000 km to the bike and havne't yet used the ABS again.

However, it's comforting to know that it's there, especially in wet or otherwise compromised traction.

I also ride a lot of 2-up and fully loaded with luggage and camping gear. Full loads and wet roads can make for delicate braking. Nice to know my friend ABS is along for the ride.

My expirience, I could live without it, (did on my bikes), but glad I got it.
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

We have a customer who was getting a bike to commute on. He was wondering if he should get ABS or not. I said if he was just riding on nice days for pleasure it was OK to skip ABS, but since he was commuting and would be riding rain or shine, feeling "up" or not he should go with ABS. He came in 3 months after buying the bike to thank us for recommending the ABS. He was on the highway in heavy rain and a 1 ton changed lanes right on top of him without signalling. He said he was sure the choices were "under the truck or over the divider into on coming traffic". He hammered the brakes and swerved to avoid. Then told me "something happened that I didn't plan on, the bike just stopped and I steered around him!". No fish tail, no tank-slapper, no crippling injury...

Another customer was riding with his friend in the states. He has ABS, the friend didn't. A deer jumped onto the road in front of them, point blank. They both crammed on the brakes. The ABS bike stopped under control. The non-ABS bike flipped the rider over the bars and came down on his neck, severing the spine. He died a few minutes later.

We've also had people ride for 20 years and never need ABS, but you only need to need it once...
 

TG6

Member
imported post

imported post

I havea R1200 GSA with ABS. I didn't want it when I ordered the bike but, because of the short supply, I accepted the bike with the ABS option. I am an old school rider and have been riding for over 30 years on the road. Yes, I could ride without it but now that I have it, I sure like the option. I would probably enjoy the bike just as much without it and wouldn't let "not having ABS" stop me from buying one. It is, after all, just an option. You don't need it on your car either, but it's nice to know you have it if youneed it. All that being said, I'm sure you are going to love your new bike, so congrats on the new ride in your stable....
 

SubMann

New member
imported post

imported post

The other thing you can do to save your bacon is to practice hard stops every time you ride. This is worth doing with or without ABS. In both cases you will be surprised how fast you can stop, especially in the wet. I stop to the limits of the ABS frequently, just so I know what it feels like, and so I wont be surprised when I "need" it. So I guess you could say I've used ABS hundreds of times. I do it on my non ABS bike as well. I recall a near miss with a grizzly where my braking practice paid off. It had a very nice coat! No ABS that time, but no skidding either.

Not to lecture or anything, it's just one of the things I do.
 

LAZ 1

New member
imported post

imported post

The only motorcycle I'veowned that has ABSis my current ride, a 2001 BMW 1150 GS. I never thought much about ABS either way - until I started riding my GS. After almost a year on it, I have to say, I like ABS IMMENSELY!!!!!

And last week, while my 1150 was in for Winterising, I took out aloaner 2005 BMW 1200 GS for the day. A VERY wet day!!

The NEW 1200 GSversion ofABS is even better than my old 1150. I did NOT really hammer on the brakes on the loaner bike, but from my day of foolin' roun' on the 1200, the newer model BMW POWER ASSISTED???INtegrated?? ABS brakes are about 20 - 30 % more effective than the old 1150 ABS brakes. Which had already impressed me.

I would DEFINITELY vote YES!! for ABS.

[;{)

LAZ 1
 
P

Pee Wee

Guest
imported post

imported post

I rode the Honda VFR800 with ABS..........................................



I guess NONE of you, cept maybe two or three, has seen me ride a street bike. It's not pretty the Punishment I put them through...Rolling endo's, stoppies...whatever the hell ya wanna call em...almost Impossible to do with ABS.

So Im sure all you Beemer riders were very upset when you took the GS out and couldn't get the bike to do one...Im sure !!

I did try and tuck the front on the Viffer...in the rain...the ABS is amazing. If your a Ham fisted rider (most are) it's the cats ass !!!:dr:
 

deuce

New member
imported post

imported post

Pee Wee wrote:
I rode the Honda VFR800 with ABS..........................................

If your a Ham fisted rider (most are) it's the cats a** !!!:dr:

Has nothing to do with being hamfisted. ABS works in emergency situations. And saves peoples asses. Twice in the last year I have been saved from crashing or worse because the bike I was riding had ABS. Once was late on one rainy night last spring. Some twit pulls a u-turn in front of me while I am doing about 70kph. I had time to say "s***TT", hit both binders and steer around the asshat, missing his rear bumper by about 2 inches.

In a panic stop or emergency stop even experienced riderswill grab a fist full of brakes. It is just the natual thing to do. With todays modern bikes the braking systems are just so good that even an experienced rider (ie BMW Nuts friend, Ian) cannot control the braking thresh-hold in a panic situation. Unfortunately for Ian it cost him his life. :(

Ihad an '04 GSwith BMWIntegral System with ABS. I hated it personally. The brakes have no"feel" and were not progressive in any way. The new '07model has been re-designed with out the power assist :clap:eek:r a less intrusive version of it. Why anyone needs power brakes on a motorcycle is beyond me?? The engineer who came up with that gem should be sent back to the Trabant factory for more training. :D
 
P

Pee Wee

Guest
imported post

imported post

Im gonna have to try one out for sure (BMW abs). I'd like to see what they're like compaired to the Honda...I hated the Honda, linked brake shit and all.:mad3:
 

BMWNut

Member
imported post

imported post

Pee Wee wrote:
Im gonna have to try one out for sure (BMW abs). I'd like to see what they're like compaired to the Honda...I hated the Honda, linked brake s*** and all.:mad3:
The BMW brakes are "semi"-integrated. Which means when you grab the front lever it puts both binders on, and when you hit the brake pedal it does just the rear. Best system in my mind, instead of having 8 of 12 pads on the front brake linked to the lever and 2 of 4 on the back and then when you hit the pedal it adds the other 4 up front and 2 in back.... What?!?!
 

SubMann

New member
imported post

imported post

deuce wrote:


In a panic stop or emergency stop even experienced riderswill grab a fist full of brakes. It is just the natual thing to do.

I disagree. In a panic situation you respond with what you have trained to do. Police, military, MotoGP etc. emphasize training so that they respond properly in a "panic" situation, which in reality is not panic, just highly stressful and built on reactions that the body had trained for.

There, another 2 cents. That makes four! Another penny and you'll have a nickel.
 

SubMann

New member
imported post

imported post


Doh! Please ignore this post. Stupid work computer sending my stuff twice!
 

deuce

New member
imported post

imported post

SubMann wrote:
deuce wrote:


In a panic stop or emergency stop even experienced riderswill grab a fist full of brakes. It is just the natual thing to do.

I disagree. In a panic situation you respond with what you have trained to do. Police, military, MotoGP etc. emphasize training so that they respond properly in a "panic" situation, which in reality is not panic, just highly stressful and built on reactions that the body had trained for.

There, another 2 cents. That makes four! Another penny and you'll have a nickel.

How about I change that to experienced 'street' riders. I have made lots of 'panic' stops without ABS because I had enough time (sometimes just a few seconds) to access the situation and re-act. ABS comes into play when you have no time to access and just have to brake NOW!! The majority of street riders, even experienced ones like myself, do not take the time or effort to 'train' or practice threshold braking/ panic braking. This is the situationwhere ABS comes into play for these riders. For me it is worth the extra $$ and weight (now negligable) of having an ABS equiped bike. It only has to save your bacon once to pay for itself.

Now I just have to find a reliable, affordable bike with ABS that I like. The '07 650 V-Strom is looking better every day. :cool:
 
P

Pee Wee

Guest
imported post

imported post

I find this problematic for manufactureres to cater to the Lowest common denominator....Just look at the Auto industry....find the dumbest Mo Fo and make something for that Idiot and then try and sell it to People with real skills and tell em it's Something they NEED...

It's like these sport bikes with 320mm Radial mounted brakes....Two finger squeeze will cause it to Flip right over in Dry conditions. Thats great for slowing down from 200+ km/h, but in town at 50km/h...you'll see these riders dropping the bikes and tucking the front all day...Trust me..I see them ALL summer!!! Once again (Noobs) who spend Zero time practicing braking.



Now look at some of these stunters who can do Rolling Endos' for 1/4 mile now....Practice your braking and IT WILL become second nature to NOT grab a hand full next time someone pulls out.



On a side note: Any one see the Canadian Tire commercial for the Back Up cameras? Some Stunned C&#T backs up over a Motorcycle and tell the stupid cops she didn't see him !! Then tries to flirt with him !! OMFG...:mad3:
 
S

Sailor

Guest
imported post

imported post

I am a new rider of 3+ years all conditions, and if I had the chance again, of course I would get ABS. It sounds new-fangled and not neccessary at first....like ABS for cars, seat belts, and water cooling. But eventually it will become the industry standard...Honda and BMW have plans in place to make all their road bikes ABS. Good.

That being said. An extra $4000 for that option is a lot, and I wouldn't sweat not having it. I don't. Practice breaking, and practice LOOKING and SEEING so as to minimize risk of needing to brake unexpectedly. Honda Goldwings have air bags too, do you feel bad about your bike not having an airbag?

Be happy.

VI
 
K

kootenay kid

Guest
imported post

imported post

MV NV wrote:
Well Hello - I just picked up a new R1200GSA 2 weeks ago - without ABS.
The tough decision was ABS or NO ABS.

It came down to price and availability. The shop had one unit in stock without ABS. Even though it is a $1800 option, to get a bike in from Alberta with ABS and a few other options that I didn't want it was going to be a $4000 up charge. They even dropped the list price by $1000 for me to take their bike - which I obvioulsy did.

Teh GSA's are really in limited supply - with pretty much all the next shipment accounted for, until say Spring. You may not have much choice in options if you want to ride before the spring.

A friend here, has a R1200GSA with ABS, he's ridden 21K kms this year and has not used it once. In four years of riding on bikes with ABS, he says has not used it at all. The pain is deactiving it when going off road - everytime you start your engine.

I have ridden 30+ years without it and seem confident in my riding skills that will be continue to be the case.

Jim
White Rock
Sounds like you made the right choice for you! Enjoy it.:tup:
 
Top