BMW vs KTM

ktmken

New member
I have never ventured into the BMW forum before!

I am a die hard KTM guy, but I had a opportunity to deliver a BMW F800GS from Kelowna to Vancouver so I jumped at the chance.



Here are my "seat of the pants" observations.

My very first observation was that the bike feels more "top heavy" than my 950 Adventure.
This is not a big deal, it just happens to be the very first thing that I noticed.









Once I was moving, I was impressed right away by the motor. The only other parallel twins I had ridden were an old Honda 450 and a BSA 650. This motor was nothing like those.
It was smooth! and it pulled hard right from the bottom.
My KTM really doesn't have a lot of low end grunt, but it really comes alive above 5000 rpm. This 800 pulls hard right from 3000 rpm , but seems to run out of steam around 6000. I put on about 500 kms and as long as you were under 5000 rpm everything was very comfortable. Above 5000 rpm there is a buzzing that comes through the bars, the seat, and the footpegs. It doesn't bother you if you are on gravel or dirt, but if you are cruising down the highway, if will get to you after a while.
5000 rpm is 120 kms/hr with stock gearing.




I really like the windshield. My head was in "clean air" so there was no helmet buffeting. (Are you listening. KTM)

The seat was ok except for the front of the seat. It goes up at too steep of an angle. It puts too much pressure on.........ummm......."the boys?"........Things go to sleep, that shouldn't go to sleep and then things get very uncomfortable. Standing up for a while gets things back to normal for a while. Because of this, I think I would be looking for an aftermarket seat.



I love the grip heaters. It was a little chilly first thing in the morning going over the pass and those grip warmers were very, very nice.

I don't like the BMW turn signal switches. I guess you would get used to it after a while, but I had to think about it every time I used them. That being said, I really like the self cancelling feature.



On gravel roads the bike was very stable. I had knobbie tires front and back so that helped a lot. I felt as comfortable on gravel roads as I do on my KTM 950.



On the highway, I think I like my KTM better. It seems to handle the highway speeds better. (120kms and up) The BMW would go into a slight speed wobble at 120km per hr. It never got out of control, but It was enough to catch your attention. I am sure it is because of the knobbie tires, but I have run knobbie tires on my 950 and not had this wobble at this speed. (on the 950 I get the same wobble around 135 km/hr)

Overall, I really like this bike. I would not hesitate to take in on a long trip to Alaska or Mexico. If I had to give up the KTM for some reason, I would definitely look at buying one of these bikes.

Thumbs up, BMW

Ken
 
I just bought one of these last week, and would agree with everything you said. The one negative point I can add is the heat that belches out of the rad on a hot day... wow! It will be nice in colder weather, I guess.

I have yet to install knobbies (using the Pirelli Scorpion "Trail" tires from the factory) and the road holding in the very tight twisties is quite amazing. I forgot what I was riding a few times, it just doesn't feel like a dual sport when ridden in anger.

I replaced a street bike and a dirt bike with this one, and with a 1500km road trip just complete, I think it's a pretty good all-in-one solution.
 

ktmken

New member
You are right about the heat. I didn't mention it but I did notice that driving around down town Vancouver on Sat afternoon, there was a lot of heat hitting my legs. I get that on my 950 also but just on the left side. (that is where the fan is)

I think you are going to be very happy with your choice.

KTMKen
 

Lone Rider

New member
Ive got the new anniversary f800gs which allready has 5000 kilos on it. I had the Heidenaus installed from new and im pretty satisfied with their performance.I dont get any wobble until about the 145-150 range,but what i do get is a lumpy feeling on the front at the70 -80 kilo range,which is some what annoying.Yes they were balanced properly and what i get from Island BMW is thats normal.Not entirely happy with that.Another little thing ive noticed is i cannot climb mountains as slowly as my xt 350 used to.A lot more feathering of the clutch is required. Other than those quibbles i love the bike its a great all around machine!
 
Last edited:

Lone Rider

New member
Not sure but i would go with them again. I had to go with a 140 this time ,there is only a marginal difference from the 150.
 
Not sure but i would go with them again. I had to go with a 140 this time ,there is only a marginal difference from the 150.

Hmmm. I understood the 150's have way more meat on them, guess I'll check my sources. Just talked to the dealer, TKC's are 40% more expensive! I can't quite figure that out...
 
They might be 40% more expensive to purchase but are they 40% more expensive to own?

Well, if you factor in cost of ownership per mile, the Heidi's seem pretty good value. I hear (secondhand, take it for what it's worth) of people getting 12-15000 miles out of a set - that's pretty good longevity. TKC's are obviously better in the rougher stuff, traction-wise though.
 
Last edited:

Bayner

New member
I didn't find the K-60 gave anything up to the TKC in the traction department. I was quite pleasntly surprisd by that actually. It chews a rut just as well in my experience.
 

joker650

Active member
Not sure if this should go in the KTM300 FS sale section...so I put here.


[video]http://www.xtranormal.com/watch/7110381/[/video]
 

Bones

Member
Joker, you have to much spare time.
That was great, Gortex whale foreskin and Husabitch. :clap::clap::clap: Poser
Cheers
Bones
 
Top