Rider Age - Requirements Questions.

vuldub

New member
Here in Alberta, my 13yo son can ride off road on forestry trails, with an offroad bike equipped with headlight and taillight. I have off road insurance for his bike. What are the rules in BC? Are forestry roads like the Gray Creek Road off limits for him? If I would like to do an overnight camping trip with himon bikes, is it possible? I ride a TW200 so, I'm all legal.

Regards...Wes
 
G

getoutside

Guest
imported post

imported post

Grey Creek FSR is still an active road with a surprising amount of traffic. I'm pretty sure you need a license and insurance.
 

vuldub

New member
imported post

imported post

So what type (classification) of road is my son legally allowed on? I have it in the back of my mind that in BC the minimum age for riders off road is 16yo?
 
G

getoutside

Guest
imported post

imported post

I can't say for sure, I do know that any FSR is considered a public use road and rider needs to be licensed. The driving age in BC is 16.
 

sparklr

New member
imported post

imported post

It would be interesting to know for sure where the law resides on this. I know up here FSR's are frequently used by Dirtbikers and ATV's (by persons under 16). While the term public use may be correct, there doesn't seem to be any enforcement. Now strictly FSR shouldn't be confused with rural residential dirt roads. The local Rod and Gun club was promoting ATV off road insurance at one point for around $100-150 for a full year, seems steep but I suppose when you suck face with a Kenworth grille there could be some expenses incurred.
 

CANADIAN BACON

New member
imported post

imported post

Thanks to BCCOM and their meddling ways "ALL" roads in BC,active or not, are considered Highway applicable and covered by ICBC.
BCCOM thought it would be a good idea if all motorcycle in the province were insured.
The only way to do that was to require the one riding the bike to be the one insuring the bike.
Welcome to the BC/BS-ICBC/BS.
Used to be an Adult could insure a machine and the youth could ride it under supervision. BY law not any more.
You can ride any where and mostly get away with it but when push comes to shove
Unless you are insured you bum is fair game.
In BC we constantly must fight with Trails BC to ride and now we have BCCOM-who is supposed to be on our side-making deals with ICBC for the off road licensing.:mad2:
I just ride and take my chances.
 

Jaeger

Member
imported post

imported post

CANADIAN BACON wrote:
Thanks to BCCOM and their meddling ways "ALL" roads in BC,active or not, are considered Highway applicable and covered by ICBC.

BCCOM thought it would be a good idea if all motorcycle in the province were insured.
The only way to do that was to require the one riding the bike to be the one insuring the bike.
Welcome to the BC/BS-ICBC/BS.
Used to be an Adult could insure a machine and the youth could ride it under supervision. BY law not any more.
You can ride any where and mostly get away with it but when push comes to shove
Unless you are insured you bum is fair game.
In BC we constantly must fight with Trails BC to ride and now we have BCCOM-who is supposed to be on our side-making deals with ICBC for the off road licensing.:mad2:
I just ride and take my chances.
Not so. All roads are not considered highways (or more properly, gazetted roads) by ICBC.

Restrictions regarding FSR's and other non-gazetted roads have existed for quite some time - back to when I was a cop and we occasionally, although very rarely, did do enforcement off the gazetted roads. The Forest Service Road Regulations have been around for a long, long time... including the 80 kph limit that nobody has ever seemed to pay much attention to, either commercial or public users.

The difference is the explosion in ATV's and other off road vehicles has made the issue very visible, and complaints from both industry and the public regarding useage has led to review and changes to the legislation. One of the biggest pushes regarding licensing is directly attributable to abuse in the province - particularly in the East Kootenays - and a lot of people are demanding licensing as a means of hopefully identifying those who refuse to play nicely with the environment.

Rather than argue the history of who done whut and how we got here, these are the legal requirements as for the government is concerned if you want to ride this road.

Liability insurance
12 (1) A person must not operate or cause to be operated a motor vehicle or trailer, other than a motor vehicle or trailer described by section 2 (5) of the Motor Vehicle Act, on a forest service road unless
(a) the driver, motor vehicle and trailer are insured under a valid and subsisting contract of accident insurance providing insurance against liability to third parties in the amount of at least $200 000, and
(b) the driver carries written evidence, supplied by the insurer, of the insurance referred to in paragraph (a), or a copy of that written evidence, and produces it, on demand, to a peace officer or an official.

And these are the particularly relevant sections of the MVA that apply as per the Forest Service Road Regulations:

"highway"includes
(a)every highway within the meaning of the Transportation Act,
(b)every road, street, lane or right of way designed or intended for or used by the general public for the passage of vehicles, and
(c)every private place or passageway to which the public, for the purpose of the parking or servicing of vehicles, has access or is invited, but does not include an industrial road;

"industrial road"means industrial road as defined in the Industrial Roads Act, and includes a forest service road as defined in the Forest Act and land designated as a development road under section 8 (1) of the Petroleum and Natural Gas Act;

24 (1)Except when accompanied by a person authorized by the Insurance Corporation of British Columbia to examine persons as to their ability to drive and operate motor vehicles, a person must not drive or operate a motor vehicle on a highway unless, in addition to any licence or permit which he or she is otherwise required to hold under this Act, the person holds a subsisting driver's licence issued to him or her under this Act of a class appropriate to the category of motor vehicle driven or operated by him or her.

194 (1)A person operating a motorcycle must ride only astride the regular seat attached to it.(2)A person, other than the operator, must not ride on a motorcycle unless
(a)it is designed and equipped to carry more than one person, and
(b)the other person rides
(i) astride the permanent and regular seat if designed for 2 persons,
(ii) astride another seat firmly attached to the motorcycle behind the seat occupied by the operator, or
(iii) on or in another seat firmly attached to one side of the motorcycle.
(3)A person who is operating a motorcycle must not permit another person to ride on it in contravention of subsection (2).
(4)Except when overtaking and passing other motorcycles, more than 2 operators of motorcycles must not operate their motorcycles side by side in the same direction in the same traffic lane.

221 (1)A person who operates or rides as a passenger on a motorcycle without properly wearing a motorcycle safety helmet commits an offence.

And there's all the other common sense stuff about driving on the right hand side of the road, yielding the right of way, stopping at the scene of an accident, not driving while impaired, etc.

So... Does your son require a driver's license? From what I know of the FSR and MVA regulations, as long as he is on a road excluded from the definition of a highway, i.e. FSR's, the answer is "No". Does he require proof of Third Party Liability Insurance? Yes.

However, I am not a cop anymore and I am not a lawyer, nor do I play one TV or the Internet. Call the local Ministry of Forests (250) 426-1700 - better yet, email them and ask for the email address of the local Compliance & Enforcement officer (ask for Mike Daigle's email address) - and ask the same question you asked here. Ask the same questions and a reference to the section of any act which requires licensing so you can read it for yourself.

That way, you'll get a printed response with somebody's name on it you can use as an authority - there's sufficient confusion out there regarding regulations on the various kinds of roads out there that it isn't exactly uncommon to find even people working in the Ministry of Forests who don't have it straight. I have run into more than one that didn't know that FSR's and mining roads were excluded from the definition of "highway".

As for taking your chances, the C&E guys have been directed to do a lot more enforcement on the roads, and that has come along with the province buying and issuing radar guns for doing traffic speed enforcement. The fines can get pretty heft - usually aren't, but get involved in an accident or something similar and you could be in far more grief than you visualized.
 

CANADIAN BACON

New member
imported post

imported post

This is all good information.
The technicalities involved are endless.
The one about youth operating a ORV./MC.
Do they require a license? probably not.
However I have been told the one operating the ORV has to be 16 or older.
Those under 16 do not qualify for insurance coverage.
This of course is in B.C.
This is the deal BCCOM worked out with ICBC 4 years ago.
Trails BC is also pushing for more restrictions on the roads.
So we as ORV users get from both sides. Trails BC/BCCOM.
 

Jaeger

Member
imported post

imported post

CANADIAN BACON wrote:
This is all good information.
The technicalities involved are endless.
The one about youth operating a ORV./MC.
Do they require a license? probably not.
However I have been told the one operating the ORV has to be 16 or older.
Those under 16 do not qualify for insurance coverage.
This of course is in B.C.
This is the deal BCCOM worked out with ICBC 4 years ago.
Trails BC is also pushing for more restrictions on the roads.
So we as ORV users get from both sides. Trails BC/BCCOM.
There are no "technicalities". This is the provincial legislation applicable to operating a motorcycle on a Forest Service Road in British Columbia as per the original question. ICBC has nothing to do with it, and BCCOM and Trails BC are not statute making authorities, no matter what initiatives they may have, good or bad.

Furthermore, there is nothing in the legislation that makes any reference to age whatsoever, and in particular for insurance coverage. Nor does it say from whom or where that insurance coverage has to come from. What it does say is that to operate your motorcycle on a Forest Service Road, the driver and vehicle must be covered by a valid third party liability insurance policy of at least $200,000. Full stop, end of story. This legislation has been in effect - along with ICBC having nothing to do with it - for a lot longer than four years.

Part of the problem with the internet is people passing on partial or misinformation. This benefits nobody, and in some cases leads to negative attitudes to people who have nothing to do with a situation.

In the spirit of that, once again, I am not a lawyer. If you want the straight goods on any question regarding legislation, then phrase your questions in a manner that will get you the answers you're looking for, ask for references to the applicable acts and sections that support the answer you're given, and MAIL it to the Minister responsible. People take considerably more care when they have to provide a written response with their name on the bottom, and it doesn't hurt to have a copy with that with you should the local police or some other authority have some warped sense of what the legislation is. It happens.

Of course, this is only the Internet. In real life, people are free to inform themselves in the manner they choose, base their conduct on the information they have in the manner they choose. The only thing in real life they won't have much control of are the consequences for their actions they may face if they didn't get adequate and accurate information.
 
S

swandog

Guest
imported post

imported post

i was reading that in the USA honda has told dealers not too sell the 50 and 70 cc crf models because they are a toy that has to high of lead levels for kids under 16
 

CANADIAN BACON

New member
imported post

imported post

Well I guess I have to dig in here and play some of my cards.
True the "Valid" insurance is an issue.
However according to ICBC anyone under 16 is not "Valid".
Neither will any B.C. private insurance company cover a rider under 16.
The legislation you speak of is in force but so is the ICBC rule.
This is a new rule less than 5 years old-give or take.
I am a member of both BCCOM and Trails BC.
Plus a lot of other groups trying to keep the trails in BC multi/use.
The insurance issue is the one Trails BC uses to the extreme.
Right now we are fighting(again) about the KVR-Kettle Valley Rail.
Any way you are right.
One must prove to their own satisfaction what will work and what will not.
Just don't think, because a ORV is insured it is valid where a rider under 16 is concerned.
The problem is BC does not have a trails policy. Although we are working on it.
I take care of my part of the province and we have a trail from Salmo to Nelson.
The BNR is a multi use trail, that the RCMP classify as a highway because it belongs to the DOH. From time to time the RCMP write tickets for no insurance but over all it's left alone.
I just talked with my local ICBC agent about insurance.
As follows
Rider must be 16 or older to operate ORV and be covered by ICBC.
Rider over 16 must have a Drivers License in order to carry a passenger on ORV.
Hope this helps.
 

vuldub

New member
imported post

imported post

Thanks everyone for the input. My take on the rules was that no one under 16 could ride on public roads in BC legally, period. I also thought that no one under 16 could get insurance in BC. Seem like my understanding was correct, but I still have an email into the enforcement people for clarification. So no one under 16 can ride in BC? Doesn't seem fair. Here in Alberta, I have offroad insurance for my kid's bike and he can ride on crown lands (not on public roads).
 

Jaeger

Member
imported post

imported post

CANADIAN BACON wrote:
Well I guess I have to dig in here and play some of my cards.
True the "Valid" insurance is an issue.
However according to ICBC anyone under 16 is not "Valid".

I just talked with my local ICBC agent about insurance.
As follows
Rider must be 16 or older to operate ORV and be covered by ICBC.
Rider over 16 must have a Drivers License in order to carry a passenger on ORV.
Hope this helps.
Ask your ICBC agent to refer you to the specific legislation and sections of that legislation that gives them any authority whatsoever over Forest Service Roads and the requirements to operate a motorcycle thereon. Help him out by pointing to the sections of the FSR Regs and MVA that clearly exclude FSR's from the definition of a "highway". Ask him to provide the answers in a letter - with his signature at the bottom.

Let us know how that goes. Then ask the local C&E officer what authority ICBC has on FSR's and how often he works with them - in the East Kootenays where the FSR road in question is, that would be Mike Daigle.

You can certainly ask ICBC if they'll sell you the required third party liability coverage. The fact that they or any other insurance company choose not to sell you that coverage doesn't mean it can't legally be done.

I've just finished arranging insuring my new WR250R in Montana - with a BC drivers license. Geico wouldn't insure me, a bunch of other companies wouldn't insure me. But Allstate and Progressive would. The point is, the fact all the others said they couldn't or wouldn't sell me insurance doesn't mean it was illegal for me to insure my bike in Montana with US insurance and a BC driver's license.

There is no age requirement. There is no license requirement. There is a requirement for $200,000 third party liability; who provides it and what jurisdiction it is from is not legislatively mandated.

ICBC will sell BC residents insurance for quads that will enable you to legally use them on highways to some extent. I do know it requires a plate and I believe a police issued permit; as you're now on a highway, now you need a driver's license as well. Whether that is just for using a designated highway only to the extent that you can get from one trail to the next, I don't know. To the best of my knowledge this insurance isn't available to off road motorcycles, but again, I don't know. It isn't relevant in the issue at discussion at any case, although I think this might be what is confusing your ICBC agent.

In closing, once again, I am not a lawyer nor do I play one on TV. You can read the FSR regs and MVA act yourself, and you can have phone conversations with insurance agents and forestry workers, and you can read message boards like this. But at the end of the day if you want definitive answers, write your answers out, ask for replies that include references to the applicable legislation and sections of that legislation, and send it in the mail. What you get back over an enforcement officer's signature will be definitive.
 

Jaeger

Member
imported post

imported post

wbader wrote:
Thanks everyone for the input. My take on the rules was that no one under 16 could ride on public roads in BC legally, period. I also thought that no one under 16 could get insurance in BC. Seem like my understanding was correct, but I still have an email into the enforcement people for clarification. So no one under 16 can ride in BC? Doesn't seem fair. Here in Alberta, I have offroad insurance for my kid's bike and he can ride on crown lands (not on public roads).
First, the term "public road" has nothing to do with the law. You will not find the term "public road" in the FSR Regulations, nor in the MVA - the term doesn't exist legally as far as the applicable legislation is concerned. It isn't a legal definition - look at the definition sections of both Acts and see if you can find it. FSR's - the vast majority of them - are freely open to the public. That has nothing to do with the legislation pertaining on how they can be legally used. Nor is age mentioned anywhere in the FSR regulations or applicable MVA regulations.

Second, age has nothing to do with getting third party liability insurance in BC for off road use. Insurance carriers may well feel the risk of insuring riders under 16 is not worth it and decline to write you a policy, but that does not mean there is a legal prohibition against them doing so. Also note that if you have the required $200,000 liability insurance from your home province and the carrier says it is valid in BC, then you meet the legal requirements. Get a letter from your carrier saying it is valid in BC before coming if you have any concerns.

Third, what I have written so far applies only to the FSR's you have asked about. There are other types of roads in BC that may well have different requirements for use - highways being the most obvious ones.

Fourth, I would have written a letter asking for specific information if I were you. Email might be quicker, but officials take more time with printed responses than emails, somebody's name and signature goes at the bottom of a letter, and it is a lot easier to carry a letter around with you than an email should you ever be stopped by police, C&E guys, etc.

Given how long it will be before the Grey Creek Pass is open, you still have lots of time.
 

CANADIAN BACON

New member
imported post

imported post

wbader wrote:
Thanks everyone for the input. My take on the rules was that no one under 16 could ride on public roads in BC legally, period. I also thought that no one under 16 could get insurance in BC. Seem like my understanding was correct, but I still have an email into the enforcement people for clarification. So no one under 16 can ride in BC? Doesn't seem fair. Here in Alberta, I have offroad insurance for my kid's bike and he can ride on crown lands (not on public roads).
Ahhh! Alberta.
The land of free thinkers and common sense.:tup:
B.C. gets your rejects.
Between 93/95 Klien did house cleaning and bought a lot of Welfare Bums a bus ticket. One way to Vancouver.
Klien not only canceled welfare checks he also put a stop to a lot of programs in the Colleges that were going no where.
These "Rejects" that ended up in BC got involved with the trails system and abandoned rail lines. They suck up Govt. Grants by the millions and use the trails system as the ploy to get their money.
The insurance issue is their biggest "come-on" and they will cry loud and long about the evils of ORV and no insurance.
Before they arrived in BC we didn't have a lot of problems.
 

vuldub

New member
imported post

imported post

Jaeger:

As I noted, I was still awaiting response from the enforcement officer. He replied andhis answer is NO. My son cannot ride on FSRs, which includes Grey Creek, unless he holds a valid drivers licence.

And from my understanding of BC driving regulations, no one under 16 years old can legally ride a motorcycle.
 

Jaeger

Member
imported post

imported post

wbader wrote:
Jaeger:

As I noted, I was still awaiting response from the enforcement officer. He replied andhis answer is NO. My son cannot ride on FSRs, which includes Grey Creek, unless he holds a valid drivers licence.

And from my understanding of BC driving regulations, no one under 16 years old can legally ride a motorcycle.
That's interesting. I spoke to the C&E officer, went over the law with him, and he said no license required.

I don't have any kids, but I am sufficiently intrigued by this now. I am going to PM my email to you. Could you please forward me the email you received regarding this, complete with headers - or a scan of the letter you received in reply. I'm particularly interested in what sections of the FSR and MVA you were quoted in support of that information, and the name of the individual who replied to you.

I did a little web search after reading your post; it seems like differing MoF views on this - and what constitutes Third Party Liability Insurance - are not uncommon in this province. It seems to me that it is time to take the question directly to the Minister responsible through our local MLA.

As for nobody under the age of 16 riding a motorcycle anywhere in this province, that is also interesting considering the number of younger kids without drivers' licenses in this province racing motocross bikes on Crown land, leased or otherwise. It also comes to mind that a few of the law enforcement personnel in this area have their young kids out at the Alkalis - Crown land - riding their bikes with all the other kids. And some of them aren't even teenagers.

Anyways, if you'll forward me that info I'll take it up with the Minister responsible. Whether you're still interested in riding here or not, there's no reason for riders in this province to be getting different answers from MoF staff/police on what constitutes legitimate insurance and whether licenses are or aren't required.

Thanks a lot. PM sent.
 

vuldub

New member
imported post

imported post

Jaeger:

I will pm you the note I got from the foresty officer.

Here in Alberta, forestry trunk roads are offlimit to unlicenced drivers and "off road" registered vehicles. The only place underaged drivers can ride is on crown lands - not on publc roads.As forestryroad or industrial road is considered a public road. So it's similar to BC in that FSR are like forestry trunk roads in Alberta.
 
Top